Archive for Jin

Claire and Aaron

Posted in Observations, Some wonderings I don't really believe, Theories with tags , , , , , , , , , , on February 27, 2010 by Scott Copperman

Most of us assume Claire died, and was “claimed” or “infected.”

She feverently wants her baby back (I always think of the Chili’s “I want my baby back, baby back…” song when I type that). Why?

I mean, duh, it’s her baby. But, she calmly left the baby in the first place, she didn’t seem concerned back when she was with Christian in the cabin, and she’s not OLD Claire, she’s been changed. Why is the baby so important…

I have two theories:

  1. (25%) At first, she was with Christian Shephard, and Christian was an agent of Jacob (as he claimed at times). Christian calmed her, assured her it was okay for the baby to be with the Losties (or Others), but then after some sort of falling out, Claire sided with Smokey and now feels that is no longer acceptable.
  2. (75%) Claire is possessed by an entity who has a connection to the ENTITY WHO POSSESSED AARON! Yes, baby Aaron did die on the island, only to be claimed when Jin gave Claire the urchin. Infected Claire wants the infected baby back.

In all honesty, I don’t particularly believe either of these, but it’s a “whoa, maybe…” kind of thing.

Be sure to check out ReThinking The Lighthouse, our most recent episode of ReThinking LOST – available on itunes and at

-Scott Copperman-


Why isn’t Jin more concerned about Sun?

Posted in Observations, Some wonderings I don't really believe with tags , , , , on February 3, 2010 by Scott Copperman

There is no reason for the Dharma-Losties to think Sun is anywhere except on the island somewhere in the 70s.

I know Jin spent some time looking for Sun, but especially after Sayid showed up in the woods – he should be believing Sun is out there somewhere.

Why isn’t he freaking out looking for her?

I know he’s a cool cucumber, as they say, but new-Jin is back in love with Sun, and he should want to protect her.

Why isn’t he more obsessed with looking for Sun?